Pizzelle maker, also known as pizzelle iron, is very similar to a waffle maker. It is usually mostly dedicated to making pizzelle, crispy Italian waffles. There is a variety of different pizzelle makers to choose from. Some can only make pizzelle or multifunctional ones that make waffles, cannolis, cookies, or even pancakes. In this article, we will help you pick the best pizzelle iron for your needs. Psst… Our top best pizzelle maker of 2020 is Cuisinart WM-PZ10 Pizzelle Press (buy on Amazon)
Floflokitchen.com best pizzelle maker picks for 2020
- Overall best pizzelle maker – Cuisinart WM-PZ10 Pizzelle Press (buy on Amazon)
- Best aluminum pizzelle iron – Palmer Pizzelle Maker Classic (buy on Amazon)
What will you find in this article?
In addition to finding the best pizzelle iron, this article has a ton of useful information like what to look for in a good pizzelle maker? How to make pizzelle batter? How to clean and maintain pizzelle maker? and other tips in our F.A.Q. Just use the table of contents below to quickly navigate the article.
Best Pizzelle Maker Reviews
Chef’sChoice 834 PizzellePro Toscano
Our nomination for Best Pizzelle Maker is the Chef’sChoice 834 PizzellePro Toscano nonstick pizzelle maker. Out of all the pizzelle makers, we think it’s the best pizzelle iron on our list because of its features, quality, and cheap price point!
This pizzelle maker is equipped with a baking indicator light that warns you when the pizzelle are finished baking, so no more burning and wasting product (However, don’t trust the light indicator too much sometimes it flashes when the pizzelle still need a few seconds to cook).
It also has an even heat press that will cook your pizzelles in a matter of seconds, because who wants to wait for this tasty treat, am I right?
The cooking time for this pizzelle maker is under 30 seconds, and with its ability to make two pizzelles at a time, you will be pizzelle making machine!
This Italian pizzelle maker has instant temperature recovery, which means that it is always ready to bake, no need to wait a long time for it to warm up.
It also has a non-stick coating, which prevents the pizzelles from sticking and provides easy cleanup.
Two added benefits are that it has a locking lid which helps with even cooking and a uniform looking pizzelle, and they are perfect for making cannolis! And yes, it does come with cannoli recipes.
The only disadvantage we can see is that it is made mostly for pizzelle and cannoli. This pizzelle press is not too good for thicker batter products like pancakes or regular waffles the latch that locks the press just won’t hold it well.
- Good quality build
- Quick baking
- Can make cannoli
- Able to make 2 big pizzelle at a time
- Instant temperature recovery
- Can’t cook thicker batter products
- Light indicator not very accurate
You might also like: Best Korean BBQ Grill for Home
VillaWare V3600-NS Prego Nonstick Pizzelle Baker
The VillaWare V3600 is one of the best pizzelle makers on the market. Even though it’s quite more expensive pizzelle maker than others, but it is a traditional brand when it comes to pizzelle and excellent quality. For us, it’s a close runner-up for best pizzelle irons, the only reason it was not nominated as our top pick was because of its higher price point.
The VillaWare bakes 2 5-inch pizzelle every 30 seconds, it also imprints the traditional Fiori pattern on each cookie, to some that may not be an important feature, but if you like tradition then this is perfect!
The inside is made with a Xylan non-stick grids, which makes cleaning a breeze! The automatic thermostat has a “ready” light that flashes indicating when pizzelle are done. However, it does not have a timer, so you will have to visually watch the light come on.
The last thing that we love about this product is that it has a steam guard that protects the hands from steam burns, a cord wrap so it can be stored on its side, and it comes with instructions and recipes.
- Really sturdy
- High-end quality
- Traditional design and imprints
- Traditional brand
- Xylon non-stick grid
- Light indicator
- Hand protector from steam
- Cooking instructions and recipes included
- No timer
- Really expensive
Palmer 1000T Electric Pizzelle Iron Non-Stick
The Palmer 1000T Electric Pizzelle Iron is Non-Stick with a very sturdy build. You can also make 2 big beautiful pizzelle at a time.
The whole build feels very well put together, no wobbly or plasticy parts.
With the whole build being very well done it does lack some basic features like temperature gauge or even a light indicator.
You basically wait till it warms up, then put in the batter and time 30 seconds yourself.
Of course, over time you will get comfortable with the timing and you will know when they are done.
We recommend waiting till it’s completely heated before you put in the batter, or else it might stick a bit more than usual.
What this model lacks, however, makes up for in quality of pizzelle that it produces. It is known to produce beautifully tan and crispy pizzelle.
It is an amazing high-quality pizzelle iron, but the lack of temperature gauge and indicator might discourage inexperienced people.
However, if you give it some practice and learn the timing this pizzelle press makes beautiful and crispy pizzelle.
- Sturdy build
- Makes big pizzelle
- No temperature gauge
- No light indicator
Cuisinart WM-PZ10 Pizzelle Press
The Cuisinart WM-PZ10 Pizzelle Press is ranked as the best pizzelle maker on our list because it is small and easy to store, is of great quality, makes big pizzelle and has great features.
This pizzelle iron does not have a long handle that would normally get in the way of storing in a cabinet, and it can also sit upright for easy storage.
This Italian pizzelle maker has a non-stick coating that makes cooking and cleaning very easy.
It can bake 2 thin 4 inch pizzelle, which is a perfect size for cannolis. Speaking of cannolis, this model comes with a wooden cannoli dowel as well as a measuring spoon.
The cover in this particular model comes with a locking lid which is both a safety feature as well it ensures a uniform and evenly cooked pizzelle.
When you lock the pizzelle press it locks really firm and does not wobble meaning it provides as a uniform cook as possible.
Cuisinart also gives you a limited 3 year warranty for this electric pizzelle press.
One unique feature that most do not have is the ability to control the temperature which is numbered 1-5. 1 would be the lowest and 5 being the highest browning setting. It also has a light that indicates when your pizzelle are done.
This high-quality, compact and easy to use pizzelle maker is an amazing choice for all cooks whether it’s your first time making pizzelle or 1000th.
- Feels really sturdy
- Great locking lid
- Light indicator
- 5 temperature settings
- 3 year limited warranty
- Compact and easy to store
- Has cannoli dowel
- Makes 2 4 inch pizzelle
VillaWare 2060 Uno Pizzelle Baker
The VillaWare 2060 is both the best aluminum pizzelle maker and an amazing compact pizzelle maker. Its simple design makes it easy to store with the ability to wrap the cord at the bottom and it does not have a bulky handle so you can either lay it on its side or upright.
It operates and looks more like a waffle iron, however, it still makes Italian cookies. This pizzelle iron makes two 5 inch pizzelle and comes with four recipes and few variations. It has the traditional floral design on the pizzelle plates, and they are constructed with non-stick cooking grids.
It is also made of aluminum for an even heat distribution.
There is a clip that locks the lid into a place that helps with even and level cooking.
This Italian cookie maker does not have temperature control so you’ll have to stick with one heat level, however, there is an indicator that warns when it is done cooking.
- Heavy-cast aluminum
- Good heat distribution
- Large 5 inch pizzelle
- Easy to store
- Lid with a clip to lock it
- Looks like a waffle maker
- No temperature control
- Not the best looking
Palmer Pizzelle Maker Classic
The palmer Pizzelle Maker Classic takes the best aluminum pizzelle maker spot on our list.
This USA made pizzelle press has high-quality aluminum and is extremely durable.
We love that you can make big 5 inch pizelle with it.
This pizzelle press is more traditional and does not have a non-stick coating like most other pizzelle makers. As long as you follow cooking instructions you shouldn’t have any trouble because it gets hot very evenly.
If you want that added security of it not sticking then you can always use some oil on it yourself, but as long as you follow instructions and don’t put the batter in before it’s heated, then it will be smooth sailing!
It may not look like it, but this pizzelle maker is electric, however, you do not have the ability to adjust the heat, nor do you have the ability to be warned when the pizzelle are done.
As we said, it’s a more traditional pizzelle iron where you need to train your timing! With some practise you should become a pro and know when it is hot enough and when they are done.
When it comes to storage this one is a little bit of a pain, it is small, however, it has a long handle and does not come with a cord tie, so the cord will be hanging out awkwardly. Despite these few shortfalls, it is of great quality and it is made in the U.S.A
- Very sturdy
- Traditional Italian cookie maker
- Durable aluminum
- Great heat distribution
- Made in the USA
- Makes 2 5 inch pizzelle at a time
- No temperature control
- No light indicator
- A bit bulky to store
You might also like: Best Pastry Board
Palmer 3 Round Pizzelle Iron
Here we have another USA Palmer product with a little twist this time. The Palmer 3 round pizzelle maker is different from your traditional pizzelle makers, in the sense that it produces 3 mini pizzelle.
Now it may not be perfect for making cannoli shells or waffle cones, but it is perfect for making snack-size pizzelle. Kids love them!
The designs on the plates vary, and they break away from your traditional patterns.
Making 3 pizzelle cookies at a time is perfect for making snacks for kids, or even for parties. The plates are made out of heavy-cast aluminum, and as long as you cook the pizzelle on proper heat, you shouldn’t have issues with sticking batter.
This model is also electric, but it only has one heat, so once it warms up you are ready to go, and like the other Palmer pizzelle iron, it does not have a done light, so that is all on you (or your practice) to know when it is ready.
Storing this will be a bit harder than other models since it’s awkward in shape, has a long handle, and does not come with a cord tie, but it is still small enough to fit into cabinets.
- Makes 3 small pizzelle at a time
- Kids love small pizzelle cookies
- 3 Different patterns
- Made in USA
- Heavy-cast aluminum
- Quite bulky to store
- No light indicator
- Non-traditional pizzelle maker
Things to consider before buying a pizzelle maker.
Pizzelle makers can be made out of a variety of materials ranging from stainless steel, which is very durable and rust-resistant and far more superior to its aluminum and iron counterparts.
If you want an easy clean up we would advise choosing a pizzelle maker that has a non-stick coating, most come with this, but there are a few that don’t have it.
The reason why some pizzelle irons are not non-stick is they want to be more traditional or want to avoid Teflon. Before Teflon manufacturers used to use PFOA in Teflon and gave a bad rep for non-stick cookware that still holds with some people. Nowadays all Teflon products are PFOA free and are safe to use as long as you don’t heat them to extreme temperatures.
Here’s an article from Healthline.com for more information on Nonstick cookware safety.
Size & Designs
Now, this really does not affect quality however it is more of a personal like and choice. Pizzelle makers are normally small and can be anywhere from 3 inches to 6 inches round. They also have different designs that can be imprinted onto the pizzelle as it cooks.
Pizzelles can vary in thickness; some can be extremely thin while others can exceed over 1/4 inch. Both taste amazing, but the thinner ones are more crispy whereas the thicker ones mimic the texture of a waffle, and sometimes do not cook on the inside completely. So it is more of a personal choice.
The old fashioned pizzelle makers were manually operated, there were no bells and whistles that told you when they were done, or at what temperature they were cooking at. Modern pizzelle makers now have timers and temperature gauges that make cooking pizzelle cookies a lot easier. When purchasing always make sure you are getting one that has a timer and a temperature gauge to make your life much easier.
What is the best pizzelle maker to buy?
Current best pizzelle makers to buy on our list are:
- Cuisinart WM-PZ10 Pizzelle Press (buy on Amazon) – This pizzelle iron is amazing for experienced people and new pizzelle cookie makers. Easy to use, good quality, temperature settings, and small enough to easily store.
- Palmer Pizzelle Maker Classic (buy on Amazon) – Aluminum pizzelle maker for more traditional pizzelle. It gets really hot and cooks crispy pizzelle in no time. This pizzelle iron might be a better option for more experienced cooks.
You might also like: How to Cook Gnocchi?
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you keep pizzelles crisp?
If you just finished cooking your crispy pizzelle cookies but will not be serving them straight away, they might lose their crispiness, especially if it’s humid. In order to keep pizzelle crisp you need:
- Straight out of pizzelle maker lay them flat and don’t stack on each other.
- Let them dry for an hour or two before storing
- Wrap pizzelle in foil or;
- Place them in paper bags or;
- Put them in cookie jars, coffee jars, or any empty jars
- Make sure the containers are NOT airtight.
How to clean a pizzelle maker?
No matter if you have a non-stick pizzelle maker, or a plain metal non-coated one, NEVER Use metal on them, when you are cooking or when you are cleaning. Meaning no a metal scrubber or a scrubber that is extremely abrasive. It will ruin both types of irons and they will constantly stick no matter what you do. That being said always wipe down with a paper towel after use and then wash with a warm soapy rag then rinse.
Should I spray my pizzelle maker with oil?
If your pizzelle maker has a non-stick coating then you should not have to spray it, but I have learned that even if it is non-stick, there will always be that one that sticks. So while your maker is pre-heating lightly mist both sides with cooking spray, and always make sure to put in the batter when it is heated up and at the proper cooking temperature, if not it will stick while cooking.
How much are pizzelle makers?
Pizzelle makers or pizzelle irons are really not that expensive. Usually, they range from $40 to $90. Obviously, you can find fancier ones that are more expensive.